Welcome to my Identification Guide to Small Winter Waders.
I was busy feeding some Turnstones at Walcott in Norfolk a few weeks ago, where they will happily take scraps left on the sea wall, when a lady approached the car and asked in an incredulous voice “what are those lovely little birds?” I explained that they were Turnstones, so named because when they are not being handed out seed and bread etc, they would naturally eke a living by turning over stones and seaweed with their slightly upturned beak in search of small crustaceans and invertebrates. I went on to tell her they were almost certainly visiting us for the winter from their summer home in the Arctic tundra. She was quite astounded because she had never noticed these birds before. The episode emphasised to me that although I take these things for granted, that is by no means the case with most people. That pleases me because it validates the need for simple, uncluttered guidance.
Waders as a group of birds are quite fascinating. They undertake immense migratory journeys, occupy just about every geographic niche and come in a colourful array of shapes and sizes. Of the 210 or so species worldwide, the UK hosts a little over 20 breeding species, but is fortunate to be visited by many more during spring and autumn migration, as well as providing refuge for huge numbers during winter. Waders are accessible birds, not for them skulking around in deep woodland, instead they generally love wide open expanses which provides them with the necessary food, roosting and nesting sites. For the casual observer, they are most easily encountered during winter when they will flock to coastal locations to probe amongst the mud and foreshore in search of choice morsels, or like those Turnstones will scurry around your feet picking up scraps. For the beginner, they can be a daunting group to identify, but with practice you will easily be able to narrow a sighting down to a small number of candidates and, more often than not, nail the identification by applying a few visual clues. That’s what this guide is all about. We will break species down into simple, manageable chunks based on size and comparable plumage, habits and habitats.
I will produce further guides to the medium and large winter waders in due course, but for now we’re going to cover five species in some detail: Knot (Calidris canutus) Dunlin (Calidris alpina), Sanderling (Calidris alba), Turnstone (Arenaria interpres) and Purple Sandpiper (Calidris maritima). We’ll split them into two smaller groups to allow close comparison of similar species. Let’s look at the first three species which are superficially alike.
Knot. The largest of the three. Rotund and grey toned, it can be seen in large swirling flocks around the Wash and other estuaries. Essential features: 1) medium length, straight, black beak, 2) grey flecks and streaks on breast and flanks, and 3) yellow/green legs.
Dunlin. A common brownish wader of muddy marshes, estuarine creeks and foreshore. Points to note: 1) Black decurved beak, 2) brown streaked breast band with clean white belly, and 3) very dark/blackish legs
Sanderling. The smallest of the group. Two tone white/grey, it generally scurries along the tide line pecking at morsels washed up by the waves. Main features: 1) small, straight, black beak, 2) bright white underparts, 3) black legs and at close range note 4) absence of hind toe.
Knot in flight. The overall impression is of a chunky grey bird. More often than not you will see them in flocks which can be large and impressive as they swirl over an estuary. Points to note: 1) Medium, straight, dark beak, 2) Sometimes shows a dark patch on the outer leading edge of the wing. 3) thin white wing stripe, and 4) grey mottled rump with grey tail.
Dunlin in Flight. Small, dark wader, generally seen singly or in small groups. Points to note: 1) Medium length, dark, decurved bill, 2) narrow white wing bar against dark wing, and 3) a most distinctive dark central area along the rump which is bordered by bright white.
Sanderling in Flight. A very small, compact wader with bright white face and underside. Points to note: 1) very short, dark bill, 2) Broad white wing bar bordered by dark feathering, and 3) grey tail.
A few more images for comparison purposes.
Flighting Knot 
Roosting Knot 
Roosting Dunlin
Feeding Knot and Dunlin – showing relative size 
Dunlin and Turnstone
Now for the Turnstone and Purple Sandpiper. Of this pair, the Turnstone is by far the most numerous around our shores and is certainly much more obvious. They are extremely confiding even to the extent of happily sharing your fish & chips or bread intended for the gulls. By comparison, Purple Sandpipers are unobtrusive, restricting their activities to picking tiny morsels from rocks and seaweed encrusted groynes where they blend in superbly well and are easily overlooked. They occasionally venture onto the foreshore, but in my experience not very often. However, the two species do associate with one another and can often be found feeding together when they will play chicken with the incoming breakers. They can look alike in poor light, but they are in fact completely different.
Turnstone. Strictly coastal, this jaunty, confiding little wader will happily feed on any proffered scraps. Erstwhile it will poke amongst seaweed encrusted rocks, strandlines and pebble strewn beaches, living up to its name in turning over stones to seek hidden invertebrates. Points to note: 1) Small, slightly upturned beak, 2) Broad black breast band, 3) Bright white underparts, 4) Short, stout bright orange legs, 5) Mottled plumage on back of various shades of brown and black, and 6) patchy, streaked head markings of brown and white
Purple Sandpiper. Nowhere near as common or confiding as the Turnstone, this wallflower amongst waders will often be found in the same habitat. It is another strictly coastal winter visitor. Points to note in comparison with Turnstone: 1) Longer, orange coloured, decurved beak, 2) smoky grey breast band, 3) grey streaked underparts, 4) longer, pale orange legs and 5) More uniform grey toned upperparts, and 6) smooth, smoky grey head
Turnstone in Flight. Points to note: 1) Short white wing bar against otherwise dark wing, 2) White shoulder patches, and 3) White central patch and white base to tail.
Purple Sandpiper in Flight. Overall smoky grey plumage with 1) White wing bar against dark grey wing, and 2) dark central patch on rump and tail with white on sides.
Purple Sandpiper Living Dangerously 
Turnstone Being Mugged
Some further images for comparison.
Turnstone, turning over stones! 
Purple Sandpiper. Typically feeding amongst seaweed covered rocks
For completeness we can also have a brief look at Ringed Plover (Charadrius hiaticula) which is really quite unmistakable although never common: 1) bold black bands on the head and breast, 2) bright orange legs and 3) uniform brown back.
In flight the bold head and chest patterning are very obvious as is the bright white wing bar and clean white underbelly.
For more guides in this series click here. For much more information on waders worldwide and how you can help their conservation visit the fantastic Wader Quest website.
Don’t forget to SUBSCRIBE to the website by entering your email in the box on the side panel.
Oh boy. Bob took us to Hartlepool and Teesmouth for the day.62 species seen. Curlew, turnstone, purple sandpiper, redshank, red throated diver, ringed and golden plover, lapwing, oystercatcher , rock pipit, Eider, red throated diver.
The turnstone was delightful.
These guides are fabulous. Thank you.
Thanks Phil, much appreciated.
This website and in particular the guides on waders are excellent. I have always avoided them as so difficult to identify. Then a helpful birds Bob helped me out at Blacktoft and ever since been spotting up on identifying these birds.
These guides to a newcomer like me are brilliant to help me hone in and look for the key identifiers of each bird.
Now all I have to do is go birding and put into practice my learning.
Now waders are very exciting group of birds and with Bobs help I am learning where to find them too. Can’t thank you all enough.
Many thanks Phil, very glad the guides have proved useful. As you say there’s no better learning experience than actually getting out amongst them. Best to simply do them one at a time and get comfortable with the common species. I remember being overwhelmed with the thousands of probing dots on local estuaries, but it eventually all falls into place. You may be interested in having a look at the WaderQuest site http://www.waderquest.net which provides lots of ID tips as well as interesting information regarding waders worldwide. Cheers
Purple Sandpiper is probably my favourite Winter wader: it’s predictable at 2 or 3 sites in Norfolk / Suffolk and can be delightfully confiding! Good photos showing the various distinguishing marks: very useful for newcomers…
Thanks David, I’ve been watching and snapping Purple Sandpipers at sea Palling lately. If you time it right with the high tide you can get pretty close.
Excellent blog Barry. As usual!
Cheers mate.